Cigars have been around for centuries, yet somehow, misinformation about them is as popular as ever.

Enter Cigar Myths.

Whether it’s social media nonsense, pseudo-science, ‘that guy’ in the lounge who pretends to know everything, or just plain stubborn ignorance, myths about cigars refuse to die. So, let’s torch some of the most persistent ones with a little common sense and maybe a touch of well-earned sarcasm (you know, I can’t help myself).

Common Cigar Myths

1. Cigars Are Just Big Cigarettes

Ah, yes, the classic line from people who don’t know what they’re talking about. A cigar is to a cigarette what a single malt Scotch is to a light beer.

One is a meticulously crafted product with history, tradition, and complexity; the other is mass-produced for quick consumption. If you think they’re the same, I have bad news for you (and your palate). Cigars and cigarettes are not the same thing, no matter how much some people want them to be.

Unlike cigarettes, cigars are not typically inhaled, contain no chemical additives, and are meant to be an occasional indulgence, not a habit-forming crutch. Comparing the two is like saying that a gourmet meal and a fast-food burger are interchangeable (ok, maybe I need a better analogy).

2. Only Old Men Smoke Cigars

Right, because Instagram, YouTube, and the ever-growing number of cigar lounges packed with people under 40 must be an elaborate illusion. If cigars were truly an old-man hobby, someone needs to explain why the industry is booming with younger enthusiasts, new brands, and modern takes on classic blends. Not only cigar smokers but many new cigar makers have entered the industry, creating new trends and followers.

3. People Inhale Cigar Smoke

This barely makes the list but my email inbox shows this still needs to be stated. If you enjoy violently coughing and questioning your life choices, go ahead. Cigars are meant to be savored, not inhaled like a desperate gasping attempt at self-destruction. It’s about the flavor, aroma, and experience—not filling your lungs with smoke like a malfunctioning exhaust pipe.

4. The Darker the Cigar, the Stronger It Is

This is the equivalent of assuming that every black car is faster than a red one. While darker wrappers (like maduro) can sometimes have bolder flavors, strength depends on the tobacco inside. Some dark cigars are smooth and sweet, while some lighter ones will surprise you. If you are passing on ‘dark’ wrapper cigars just becuase you think they are strong, you are missing out on a lot of great cigars. [Note: Don’t get all snooty strong cigar guys…you are doing the same if you are passing on all light colored wrappers.]

5. You Can Re-Light a Cigar as Many Times as You Want

Sure, and you can also reheat your steak five times and pretend it’s still perfectly cooked. The reality? A cigar that’s been abandoned for too long loses its character, and excessive relighting leads to acrid, charred flavors. If you don’t have the time, pick a shorter cigar instead of committing crimes against good tobacco.

6. More Expensive Means Better

Price doesn’t always equal quality. Sometimes you’re paying for branding, rarity, a fancy box, or just plain hype. There are fantastic budget-friendly cigars that outshine overpriced status symbols. If you think a $50 cigar automatically beats a $10 one, you might as well start rating wines by how fancy the label looks.

7. Cigars Don’t Go Bad

Cigars, properly stored, can last a very long time but they’re not indestructible. Sure, they won’t rot like milk, but leave them out of proper humidification, and you’ll be smoking something with the texture of a twig or the aroma of old cardboard. Cigars need care—unless you like the idea of turning a premium smoke into a sad, brittle disappointment.

Sadly, this list of ‘cigar myths’ could have been a lot longer. Matter of fact, leave your comment below on one you would add to the list.